Family Office ClubText or WhatsApp (808) 600-9260 · WhatsApp

Testing whether a family can carry illiquid commitments

This page turns Richard C. Wilson's writing on family offices into a plain test for illiquid commitments.[1][2] Endowment trustees, investment staff and fund managers who raise capital can read it as a set of questions about time horizon, cash needs, concentration, records and rules.[1][2][3][4] Families who study the endowment model can ask the same questions of their own portfolios.[2]

Start with the time horizon and the cash need

Richard C. Wilson notes that at a high enough level, the time horizons of a single family office seem so long that short term cash and income needs become negligible.[2] Some of these offices concentrate in areas where they are confident and hold a strategic edge.[2] They then invest for the long term.[2]

That does not end the matter. In a conversation recorded for a Richard C. Wilson book draft, a family office executive said that a strategic edge or operational expertise gives a significant advantage.[2] The same executive said a family still needs to pay attention to asset liability matching.[2] The aim is to avoid a liquidity crunch at an inopportune time.[2] Long horizons are not a substitute for matching.[2]

Asset liability matching puts one question to every commitment. When might the cash be needed, and can the rest of the portfolio meet that need?[2]

See what weak matching costs

The same discussion describes a family office where asset liability matching was not occurring.[2] That office had to keep a higher cash level than needed.[2] The reason was uncertainty about future capital requirements, given the illiquid nature of the majority of the portfolio.[2]

This is a useful picture of the cost. When future needs are unclear and most assets are illiquid, cash sits idle as a buffer.[2] A family that can map its future capital requirements can hold less of that buffer.[2] Administration matters here too. Richard C. Wilson describes family office administration as formal reporting, value calculations and distribution calculations for various members of the family.[1]

Check concentration in one illiquid asset

An article reproduced in Wilson's book material points to a concentration risk. More than 50% of family offices own an associated family business, while others have significant investments in private equity transactions.[4] A disproportionate part of a family's wealth can quickly be consumed into a single illiquid asset class investment.[4] In such situations, it is common to see more than 50% of a family's wealth concentrated in family enterprises.[4]

From a wealth portfolio management view, this is described as undesirable.[4] Families may take on unrecognized risks, which can mean lower returns for family shareholders and less liquidity.[4] The core problem is the misalignment of family business assets with the overall family investment portfolio.[4] A concentration check asks how much of the family's wealth sits in one illiquid asset class, and whether that matches the rest of the portfolio.[4]

Check the records, the rules and the lockups

Traditional accounting is more challenging for a family office than for a typical business because of illiquid assets.[1] Richard C. Wilson lists real estate, operating businesses, large public stock market investments, hedge fund allocations, and venture capital or private equity commitments.[1] Any of these may pose valuation challenges and potential tax liabilities.[1] Creating systems and processes to handle this requires powerful technology solutions.[1] At many small to mid sized family offices, the accounting and administration work is outsourced.[1]

A governance policy document helps communicate how decisions are made.[3] It outlines who has the power to change investment portfolio allocation, approve profit distributions from the family office to family members, and decide when the next generation receives capital and how.[3] It can also guide the family through losses in the investment portfolio overall or a dispute.[3]

Poor liquidity and lockups are among the issues that have driven single family offices away from hedge funds.[3] Richard C. Wilson writes that investors put up with many inconveniences when a manager produces consistently strong returns.[3] What they will not accept is consistently bad performance added to other issues.[3] Whether the vehicle is a hedge fund, a private equity fund or another structure, a family office that sees no returns will think seriously about finding someone else, often internally.[3]

Steps you can take

  1. List every illiquid holding the family has, including real estate, operating businesses and private fund commitments.
  2. Write down when future capital requirements may arise and how large they could be.
  3. Match those expected needs against the assets that can meet them without a forced sale.
  4. Measure how much of the family's wealth sits in one illiquid asset class or family enterprise.
  5. Confirm that reporting, valuation and distribution calculations can be produced for every holding.
  6. Record in a governance policy who can change allocations and approve distributions.
  7. Review lockup terms and past returns before adding a new commitment.

Any of these illiquid investments may pose valuation challenges and potential tax liabilities. Creating systems and processes to accomplish this requires some powerful technology solutions.

Richard C. Wilson, How to Start a Family Office

Questions people ask next

What is asset liability matching?

In a conversation recorded for a Richard C. Wilson book draft, a family office executive said families need to pay attention to it to avoid a liquidity crunch at an inopportune time.[2]

Why does concentration in one illiquid asset class matter?

A disproportionate part of a family's wealth can quickly be consumed into a single illiquid asset class investment.[4] The core problem is the misalignment of family business assets with the overall family investment portfolio.[4]

What do illiquid assets add to family office accounting?

Richard C. Wilson writes that illiquid assets make traditional accounting more challenging for a family office than for a typical business.[1] They may pose valuation challenges and potential tax liabilities.[1]

Sources
  1. Richard C. Wilson, How to Start a Family Office
  2. Richard C. Wilson, Family Office book (Wiley)
  3. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
  4. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office

Related pages

Talk to Richard

Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes Endowments.com. If you work at an endowment, advise one, raise capital from one, or run a family office that studies the endowment model, reach him directly. There is no form on this site.

Educational content only. Not investment, tax or legal advice. Endowment figures on profile pages come from the sources named on those pages.