Family Office ClubText or WhatsApp (808) 600-9260 · WhatsApp

Rebalancing when private commitments will not move

This guide explains how families and endowment teams can think about portfolio choices when some assets are difficult to move. It matters because liquidity, fees, risk, and manager performance affect how an allocation can be managed over time.[1][2]

Start with what can move

A portfolio can include traditional investments such as mutual funds, separate management accounts, ETFs, and bond funds, alongside alternatives such as hedge funds, managed futures, private equity, and venture capital. Traditional managers can offer liquidity and, in some cases, a relatively low cost basis. Alternative managers may use different strategies in pursuit of returns.[2]

When a private commitment cannot be moved, the remaining portfolio still has choices. A family office executive Richard C. Wilson interviewed described putting about half of the equity allocation into index products, where the focus is cost and flexibility, and the other half into very active equity managers. The example shows that an allocation can include distinct approaches within one asset class.[2]

For endowment staff and trustees, this provides a way to frame the discussion: identify which holdings are less liquid, then consider the flexibility of the assets that remain available for allocation decisions. [2]

Match liquidity across the investment

Liquidity needs to be considered at the level of the underlying instrument as well as the investment structure. Richard C. Wilson writes that the liquidity of the instrument must match the liquidity of the structure.[2]

A fund document may describe an investment as liquid, but the underlying holdings can be difficult to sell. Richard C. Wilson stresses understanding the actual liquidity of the instrument, rather than relying only on what documents say.[2]

When a commitment is hard to exit, staff and managers can make that constraint visible in portfolio discussions. They can consider how the liquidity of other holdings fits with the structure and the underlying assets.[2]

Review the manager and the tradeoffs

Fees are one concern when evaluating a manager. Other concerns named by Richard C. Wilson include lack of transparency, potential for large losses, poor liquidity, and lockups. He also writes that mediocre or poor performance can lead investors to look elsewhere.[1]

A review can weigh fees, performance, transparency, and liquidity together. The source describes investors weighing the fee burden of a large hedge fund with average performance against a less proven fund with lower fees and less assets under management.[3]

Richard C. Wilson also writes that families consider internal investment teams, including trading units, as a way to manage investments internally. They note that hiring trading talent can be expensive, so this approach is relevant when a family is active in hedge fund investing.[3]

Keep policy and risk appetite in view

In an interview with Richard C. Wilson, a family office executive connected the investment policy statement with risk appetite. The executive observes that people may feel less comfortable with market declines than they expected when they first defined their risk appetite.[3]

That point can inform a review when private commitments cannot be changed easily. Teams can revisit whether the policy and stated risk appetite still describe how decision makers feel about the portfolio as markets move.[3]

Different investment types can serve different roles in a portfolio. Richard C. Wilson writes that traditional managers often form a core allocation, while alternatives may be used for their range of strategies.[2]

Steps you can take

  1. List the holdings and identify which commitments are difficult to move.
  2. Separate the underlying assets from the investment structures that hold them.
  3. Review liquidity, fees, transparency, and performance for each manager.
  4. Map the available allocation choices across traditional and alternative investments.
  5. Discuss whether internal management fits the family’s level of hedge fund activity.
  6. Revisit the investment policy and risk appetite as market conditions change.

The liquidity of the instrument must match the liquidity of the structure.

Richard C. Wilson, Family Office book (Wiley)

Questions people ask next

What should a team examine when a private commitment is illiquid?

Examine the actual liquidity of the underlying instrument and whether it matches the liquidity of the investment structure.[2]

What manager issues can matter besides fees?

Richard C. Wilson names transparency, potential for large losses, liquidity, lockups, and performance among the issues investors consider.[1]

Can families manage some investments internally?

Richard C. Wilson writes that families consider in-house trading units, particularly when they are active in hedge fund investing, while noting that trading talent can be expensive to hire.[3]

Sources
  1. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
  2. Richard C. Wilson, Family Office book (Wiley)
  3. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office

Related pages

Talk to Richard

Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes Endowments.com. If you work at an endowment, advise one, raise capital from one, or run a family office that studies the endowment model, reach him directly. There is no form on this site.

Educational content only. Not investment, tax or legal advice. Endowment figures on profile pages come from the sources named on those pages.