Family Office ClubText or WhatsApp (808) 600-9260 · WhatsApp

Taxable capital and the endowment comparison

This guide draws on Richard C. Wilson's family office writing to show how fund performance measures, manager concerns and governance questions can be compared. Richard C. Wilson’s writing on family offices offers useful comparisons for endowment trustees, staff, CIOs, fund managers, and families studying the endowment model.[1]

Compare funds on more than one measure

A single performance number gives only part of the picture. Richard C. Wilson describes IRR as a common measure of private equity fund performance and says it helps investors understand returns and compare a fund with other investments.[1] For an endowment investment office, that comparison can be one part of reviewing a proposed allocation or looking back at a manager’s results.[1]

The review can also ask when the fund began investing, how funds from the same vintage performed, what returns remained after fees and expenses, and how results compared with a public benchmark.[1] Other questions include the fund’s quartile, distributions to paid in capital, and typical holding period.[1] Considering these measures together gives staff a set of specific questions to bring to a long term private equity allocation review.[1]

Wilson also describes EBITDA as a way to express what a portfolio company achieved during a fund’s investment.[2] That measure can sit alongside fund returns when staff examine what changed at a company over the holding period.[2] Together, the measures address both reported investment performance and activity at the portfolio company level.[1][2]

Look at costs, liquidity, and performance together

Fees are one concern Wilson identifies in manager selection.[1] He also names transparency, potential losses, poor liquidity, and lockups as issues that can lead family offices to look elsewhere.[1] These considerations are relevant to an endowment comparison because a return figure alone does not describe the terms or constraints attached to an investment.[1]

Wilson says performance matters alongside those concerns, and that consistently poor performance can prompt an investor to consider another manager or internal investing.[1] His discussion describes an in house trading unit as one response some single family offices have used to replicate a hedge fund model internally without its fees.[1] This is a comparison of possible approaches, rather than a claim that one structure fits every investor.[1]

Alternative investments can use multiple types of trading and investment strategies, while traditional investment managers include mutual funds, separate accounts, ETFs, bond funds, and variable annuities.[3] Wilson describes traditional managers as potentially serving as core portfolio holdings because of the number of funds, liquidity, and, in some cases, relatively low cost.[3] He also writes that traditional managers alone may not be enough for most family offices.[3] For endowment staff, these observations frame a comparison of the role, liquidity, and cost of different investment categories.[3]

Put allocation decisions inside governance

An investment policy process can clarify how changes are made and who approves an investment.[1] Wilson’s governance questions include what controls confirm due diligence, how conflicts are disclosed and addressed, and who decides the portfolio share assigned to asset categories.[1] These questions can help trustees and investment staff make the decision process visible before an allocation is approved.[1]

Governance can also define how authority is shared.[4] Wilson describes a family office governance policy as a way to communicate how decisions are made, including portfolio allocation changes, and to guide a family through major portfolio losses or disputes.[4] For families studying endowments, that idea connects portfolio decisions with written rules about responsibility and oversight.[4]

Objective performance indicators can help management and team members assess whether goals and standards are being met.[1] Wilson says these indicators can be monitored daily or weekly and can support objective comparison among team members.[1] A consistent review process can therefore consider both investment outcomes and the work of the people responsible for managing them.[1]

Make the comparison useful over time

The comparison becomes practical when staff record the questions they want answered before making a long term allocation.[1] Those questions can cover return measures, fund vintage, fees and expenses, public benchmarks, quartile, distributions, and holding period.[1] Recording the answers gives trustees and staff a basis for discussing what the reported performance does and does not show.[1]

A review can also revisit the investment policy, approval process, due diligence controls, conflict handling, and allocation authority.[1] Those governance topics shape how a decision is made, while performance measures describe what happened in an investment.[1] Keeping both sets of questions in view gives endowment staff and families a clear structure for discussing taxable capital and the endowment comparison.[1]

Steps you can take

  1. Write down the performance measures to review before comparing funds.
  2. Record the fund vintage, after fee returns, benchmark comparison, quartile, distributions, and holding period.
  3. Review transparency, potential losses, liquidity, lockups, and fees alongside performance.
  4. Clarify who approves investments and allocation changes.
  5. Set controls for due diligence and a process for disclosing and addressing conflicts.
  6. Choose objective performance indicators and set a monitoring rhythm.
  7. Revisit the governance process when reviewing long term allocations.

The most common performance measurement is probably the Internal Rate of Return (IRR), which is the annual yield on a private equity investment.

Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)

Questions people ask next

Which measures can help compare private equity funds?

Wilson identifies IRR, vintage year, same vintage fund performance, returns after fees and expenses, public benchmark comparison, quartile, distributions to paid in capital, and typical holding period.[1]

What concerns can matter beyond fees?

Wilson names transparency, potential losses, poor liquidity, and lockups, alongside performance.[1]

What governance questions belong in an investment review?

Wilson raises approval authority, due diligence controls, conflict disclosure and response, and who decides portfolio allocation among asset categories.[1]

Sources
  1. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
  2. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
  3. Richard C. Wilson, Family Office book (Wiley)
  4. Richard C. Wilson, How to Start a Family Office

Related pages

Talk to Richard

Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes Endowments.com. If you work at an endowment, advise one, raise capital from one, or run a family office that studies the endowment model, reach him directly. There is no form on this site.

Educational content only. Not investment, tax or legal advice. Endowment figures on profile pages come from the sources named on those pages.