How do performance fees and hurdles work for endowment capital?
Performance fees compensate fund managers for positive results rather than mere presence or credentials[1]. Investors negotiate creative fee structures, benchmark hurdles, and performance only arrangements to align incentives and protect capital against paying for negative returns[1]. Many family offices also seek co-investments to reduce overall fees on private equity investments and circumvent the typical fund structure.[2][3]
Aligning Incentives Through Performance Fees and Benchmarks
Richard C. Wilson explains that investors often benefit from asking for performance only fee structures instead of simple fee discounts[1]. Under these arrangements, capital allocators avoid paying advisory or management costs when an investment manager loses money overall or underperforms relative to an agreed benchmark hurdle[1]. Richard C. Wilson emphasizes that fees should be paid for producing positive results rather than merely showing up with industry credentials[1].
Investors frequently face the risk of large funds collecting substantial management fees while generating average or mediocre performance[3][2]. When managers prioritize asset gathering to safeguard their fixed fee income, they may avoid taking necessary trading risks, causing their vehicles to look like mutual funds with high fees[2]. To counter this concern, some investment offices launch internal trading units to replicate strategies in house without paying typical external manager fees[3].
Co-Investments and Fee Reduction Strategies
Direct investment structures and co-investments serve as another primary method for capital allocators to manage fee burdens[2][3]. In co-investment models, fund sponsors may forego standard management fees and performance fees because the co-investing partner benefits from sourcing and diligence work already completed by the main fund[2]. This structure functions as an incentive and reward for participating limited partners[2].
By participating in co-investments, limited partners reduce aggregate private equity fees, gain greater control over portfolio companies, and build internal operational capabilities[3]. These arrangements require careful structural coordination because creating special purpose vehicles or parallel co-investment funds introduces operational complexity and costs for general partners[2][3].
Evaluation Governance and Diligence Process
Disciplined allocation requires formal oversight through an investment committee and structured decision processes[2][4]. Some single family offices evaluate investment funds through a multi step process that ends with an Investment Committee presentation to the family decision maker and then contract execution.[2][3] Investment committees review research and portfolio movement data systematically before presenting formal cases to decision makers[2][4].
A formal investment committee prevents unplanned allocations and enforces strategic discipline across illiquid assets[4]. Some family offices credit their willingness to walk away from a deal, even at a late stage, as a big reason for their success.[2][3]
Also, many times it may be more beneficial to not ask for reduced fees but instead for performance- only fees so you are not paying for their services when they lose you money or lose you money relative to a benchmark that you establish together.
Questions people ask next
Why do allocators request performance only fee structures?
Allocators use performance only fees so they do not pay managers who lose capital or underperform established benchmarks[1].
How do co-investments alter traditional performance and management fees?
Fund sponsors often forego management and performance fees on co-investments because the diligence was already completed for the main fund vehicle[2].
What problems arise when managers rely heavily on fixed management fees?
Managers may avoid calculated investment risks to protect their asset base from redemptions, collecting high fees while producing average returns[3][2].
Sources
- Richard C. Wilson, Centimillionaire Strategies
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
- Richard C. Wilson, Family Office book (Wiley)
Related pages
- Should a family pay institutional-style fees on taxable capital?
- Why is chasing last year's performance a problem?
- What questions should a trustee ask about fees?
- What makes endowment capital different from family office capital?
- What is inbound capital raising from endowments?
- What is a practical way to work through a DDQ?
Talk to Richard
Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes Endowments.com. If you work at an endowment, advise one, raise capital from one, or run a family office that studies the endowment model, reach him directly. There is no form on this site.
Educational content only. Not investment, tax or legal advice. Endowment figures on profile pages come from the sources named on those pages.