Family Office ClubText or WhatsApp (808) 600-9260 · WhatsApp

Manager concentration risk in a smaller institution

Manager concentration risk is easy to overlook when a team is small. This page draws on what Richard C. Wilson writes about family offices and on interviews he has held. Endowment staff, trustees and families who study the endowment model can read these ideas as a way to think about manager choice. In The Single Family Office, a family office voice describes looking at concentration risk and liquidity risk as one of the key functions of a family office.[1]

Why concentration risk earns a place on the agenda

In The Single Family Office, a family office voice says an ideal portfolio construction plan is something the office always works towards[1]. Looking at concentration risk and liquidity risk is described as one of its key functions[1]. The same voice calls the plan quite dynamic[1].

The same book describes a family that stopped being a financial investor and became a strategic investor[1]. It looked at businesses where it believed it added value, through domain knowledge, geographic expertise or other ways, and not just money[1]. New opportunities had to pass a test of people it trusts, businesses it understands and geographies it knows[1]. The family believes this greatly reduced the risk of being a passive investor[1]. It also notes there could be some concentration risk if there are not enough domains to invest in[1].

Fees, size and the choice of manager

Richard C. Wilson asks a plain question about manager choice. Is it better to risk feeding an overgrown hedge fund more fees for average performance, or to take a risk on a less proven fund with lower fees and less AUM[1]? He notes that some managers have billions of dollars in assets and keep justifying their fees with outstanding consistent performance and inventive trading strategies[1].

He also writes that the fear of billion dollar hedge fund titans growing comfortable and getting fat off fees is a real concern[1]. That concern has led many single family offices to look in other places for alpha[1]. Some have launched an internal trading unit to replicate the hedge fund model without the fees[1].

Fees are not the only reason. Lack of transparency, poor liquidity and lockups have also driven single family offices away[1]. Richard C. Wilson writes that perhaps the most important factor is simply mediocre or poor performance by a hedge fund[1].

Process, checks and honest questions

A family office executive Richard C. Wilson interviewed said that hedge fund managers define their investment processes in great detail[2]. In that view, it is not about one person's talent or one analyst's ability to find investments[2]. The executive added that following the investment policy, the risk policies and the committee meetings with discipline may raise the chances of meeting goals[2].

One interview in the Family Office book describes why a firm built internal checks and balances and peer reviews[3]. After many hours of research and travel to meet managers, that effort has to be treated as a sunk cost when the decision comes[3]. If you cannot honestly say a manager is a fantastic addition after taxes, fees and volatility, then the interviewee says you simply should not do it[3].

The same book describes looking at a manager's peer group and asking whether the manager stays true to what it intends to do[3]. A small cap manager that starts holding assets no longer small by capitalization is one example[3]. An interviewee in the book says products are sold to families based on hopes, not risks.[4] The interviewee describes breaking the hypnotic focus on promised performance as the hardest job for any family office.[4]

Liquidity and flexibility in the plan

Cash flow and liquidity are always a concern with direct investments, and one family office voice deploys surplus funds only[1]. That voice would not pass a good opportunity only because it does not fit the ideal portfolio plan[1]. Instead it would look for ways to make the investment while adjusting other parts of the operating businesses, or in a worst case adjusting the plan[1].

A family office executive Richard C. Wilson interviewed said the liquidity of the instrument must match the liquidity of the structure[2]. The executive also said an investor needs proper talent and support to protect itself and achieve its mission[2].

Steps you can take

  1. List every manager and note how much of the portfolio rests on each one.
  2. Write down the concentration and liquidity checks the office runs on a regular basis.
  3. Ask whether a manager adds value beyond fees, size and a promised return.
  4. Review transparency, liquidity and lockup terms alongside performance.
  5. Use peer reviews and internal checks so research hours do not decide the outcome.
  6. Check that the liquidity of each holding matches the liquidity of its structure.
  7. Revisit the portfolio plan often, since it is dynamic.

There are many issues beyond fees that have driven single family offices away, such as a lack of transparency, poor liquidity and lockups, etc.

Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office

Questions people ask next

Why does concentration risk matter for a small team?

A family office voice in The Single Family Office describes looking at concentration risk and liquidity risk as one of the key functions of a family office.[1] The same voice calls the portfolio construction plan quite dynamic.[1]

What do families weigh besides fees when choosing a manager?

Richard C. Wilson lists a lack of transparency, poor liquidity and lockups as issues beyond fees[1]. He adds that mediocre or poor performance is perhaps the most important factor[1].

How can a team avoid picking a manager only because it has done a lot of research?

One interview describes internal checks and peer reviews that treat research time as a sunk cost[3]. The interviewee says that if you cannot honestly say yes after taxes, fees and volatility, you simply should not do it[3].

Sources
  1. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
  2. Richard C. Wilson interview with a family office executive
  3. Richard C. Wilson, Family Office book (Wiley)
  4. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)

Related pages

Talk to Richard

Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes Endowments.com. If you work at an endowment, advise one, raise capital from one, or run a family office that studies the endowment model, reach him directly. There is no form on this site.

Educational content only. Not investment, tax or legal advice. Endowment figures on profile pages come from the sources named on those pages.