How should an endowment map risk and return before picking managers?
Mapping a risk and return outlook begins by setting reasonable trade-offs for each asset class before selecting outside fund managers[1]. One family office executive suggests setting return expectations for each asset class using long data series, and says their firm uses 20 years.[1] Deciding which risk profile is acceptable directs all subsequent portfolio construction and manager selection choices[1].
Establishing Return Expectations and Model Portfolios
Investment committees spend time discussing reasonable return expectations for each distinct asset class[1]. Long data series covering twenty years provide the foundation for these return estimates[1]. Once participants agree on possible returns, they map the specific portfolios required to reach those target levels[1].
Staff members then build four or five model portfolios to evaluate different potential paths[1]. Calculating the risks tied to each of these model portfolios allows the committee to compare trade-offs directly[1]. Breaking the focus on promised performance as the sole decision metric remains essential when establishing these baseline models[1].
Testing Portfolios with Risk Metrics and Historical Scenarios
Risk across model portfolios is measured using concrete metrics such as Value at Risk[1]. Teams also test these models against severe historical stress scenarios[1]. These historical stress tests include the Dot-com burst, the events of September 11, and the Lehman collapse[1]. Selecting the risk profile that the governing body finds acceptable drives all other portfolio decisions before any capital is committed to specific managers[1].
Committee Oversight and Manager Screening
Investment committees gather regularly to discuss overall portfolio construction, evaluate current allocations, and review risk management implementation[1]. The committee structure provides a forum to debate prospective opportunities transparently and decide how capital should be allocated[2]. Any new investment typically passes through the committee as a standard stage of the investment process[1].
When evaluating managers to fill portfolio allocations, offices start with statistical screening based on measures of risk and return[3]. Analysts review track records across different market environments and examine the amount of risk taken for each unit of return[4]. Ongoing oversight tracks manager adjustments and monitors for style drift to preserve the agreed portfolio balance[3].
The role of an investment committee is to help make strategic investment decisions, evaluate or select fund managers, discuss portfolio construction and risk management approaches and implementation, and to ensure the long-term preservation of capital and implementation of the investment policy they have been given.
Questions people ask next
What data time horizon is used when setting return expectations?
Investment teams use long data series, such as twenty years of history, to establish reasonable return expectations across asset classes[1].
Which historical crisis events are used to test portfolio risk?
Portfolios are tested against historical scenarios including the Dot-com burst, September 11, and the Lehman collapse[1].
What role does an investment committee serve in portfolio design?
An investment committee meets to discuss portfolio construction, evaluate risk management approaches, and ensure long term capital preservation[1].
Sources
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
- Richard C. Wilson, How to Start a Family Office
- Richard C. Wilson, Family Office book (Wiley)
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
Related pages
- Why do managers resist co-investment rights?
- What principles should be written down before an allocation is chosen?
- What governance documents should exist before a policy portfolio is set?
- What cash demands should a family list before it copies an institution?
- How should a family test illiquidity before making private commitments?
- Can a family get the same private managers an endowment uses?
Talk to Richard
Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes Endowments.com. If you work at an endowment, advise one, raise capital from one, or run a family office that studies the endowment model, reach him directly. There is no form on this site.
Educational content only. Not investment, tax or legal advice. Endowment figures on profile pages come from the sources named on those pages.