Family Office ClubText or WhatsApp (808) 600-9260 · WhatsApp

How a family should read institutional performance stories

Families reviewing manager performance weigh returns against fees, liquidity, lockups, transparency and the risk of large losses.[1][2] Families and endowment trustees study these narratives to evaluate whether external managers truly create value beyond broad market movement[1][2]. Understanding how to review track records helps investment committees separate promotional claims from sound portfolio management[1].

Breaking the focus on promised performance

Financial products are frequently presented to families based on hopes rather than operational risks[1]. The financial industry often encourages a single focus on promised returns, which makes rigorous analysis difficult for family offices[1]. Families must recognize that past performance does not serve as a warranty for future results[2].

When evaluating external asset managers, single family offices look beyond headline returns[1]. Issues such as high fee burdens, limited liquidity, lockups, potential for severe losses, and lack of transparency drive investors away from poorly performing funds[1][3]. If returns fail to materialize, offices seek alternative paths, such as managing assets internally[1].

Aligning fee structures with realized returns

A central problem in reviewing manager performance is determining whether fees are justified by consistent results[3][2]. Large funds can accumulate significant assets under management and collect management fees while delivering mediocre returns[1][3]. Richard C. Wilson notes that fees should be paid for positive results rather than simply paying an entity for being in business[2].

Richard C. Wilson suggests that it may be more beneficial to ask for performance only fees, so you are not paying when a manager loses money or underperforms a benchmark you establish together.[2] When managers produce consistent high quartile results, investors accept certain operational inconveniences[1][3]. Without those returns, families seek lower fee alternatives or build in house trading units to avoid unnecessary overhead[1][3].

Liquidity realities and long term horizons

In private equity, an increase in EBITDA during ownership usually translates into a higher valuation of the company at exit.[3] The main operational risk in these strategies remains the lack of liquidity during economic downturns[3]. When portfolios require rebalancing, an inability to redeem capital from struggling investments creates severe portfolio strain[3].

Family offices often possess an advantage over institutional peers because they can wait through difficult market cycles without facing corporate mandates to sell assets prematurely[3]. Forced selling during short term panics creates costly losses for an institution[3]. Families that assess performance records carefully account for these lockup requirements before committing capital[1][3].

Committee discipline and sunk cost bias

Evaluating institutional performance requires strong internal governance and committee review[3][1]. Research demonstrates that spending substantial time researching fund managers creates psychological pressure to select one rather than walking away[4]. One multi family office executive interviewed in the book says all that research and travel time has to be treated as a sunk cost, and that a manager who is not a clear addition after taxes, fees and volatility should be declined.[4]

One family office CIO interviewed in the book suggests committees meet monthly on performance monitoring, policy benchmarks and risk management, semi-annually on asset allocation policy, and annually on remuneration and ethical standards.[1] That interviewee also suggests an odd number of members, including the chief investment officer, chief operating officer, family members and independent professionals.[3][1] This structure helps investment offices maintain objective standards when assessing track record claims[1][4].

Steps you can take

  1. Identify all fee layers, lockup periods, and liquidity constraints before evaluating headline performance figures.
  2. Structure manager agreements with performance based fee hurdles relative to established benchmarks.
  3. Form an investment committee with an odd number of members including independent professionals.
  4. Review performance monitoring, policy benchmarks, and risk management rules on a monthly basis.
  5. Treat all prior research and manager meeting hours as sunk costs when deciding whether to allocate.
  6. Decline manager allocations if projected net returns after fees, taxes, and volatility do not add clear value.

Questions people ask next

Why do single family offices move away from large hedge funds?

Single family offices move away due to mediocre performance, high fees, lack of transparency, and poor liquidity lockups[1][3].

How often should an investment committee review performance benchmarks?

One family office CIO interviewed in the book suggests monthly meetings for performance monitoring, policy benchmarks and risk management.[1]

What advantage do families have over certain institutions in illiquid investments?

Families can often afford to wait through difficult market cycles rather than being forced by corporate policies to sell prematurely[3].

Sources
  1. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
  2. Richard C. Wilson, Centimillionaire Strategies
  3. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
  4. Richard C. Wilson, Family Office book (Wiley)

Related pages

Talk to Richard

Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes Endowments.com. If you work at an endowment, advise one, raise capital from one, or run a family office that studies the endowment model, reach him directly. There is no form on this site.

Educational content only. Not investment, tax or legal advice. Endowment figures on profile pages come from the sources named on those pages.