Do outside members help an investment committee?
Yes, outside members can help an investment committee[1]. Richard C. Wilson teaches that at least one voice from outside can offer a unique perspective and reduce the chance of groupthink[1]. The guidance here comes from the books by Richard C. Wilson on single family offices[1].
What outside members add
Richard C. Wilson suggests inviting one to three outside experts to join the Committee[1]. Having at least one voice from outside can offer a unique perspective[2]. It can also reduce the chances of falling into groupthink[2].
Richard C. Wilson also suggests including at least one other trusted single family office executive or outside ultra wealthy family member on the Committee[2]. In one interview in Richard C. Wilson's Family Office book, a family office executive described a committee run by the Chief Investment Officer with in house people, research people and very often outsiders who sit in[3]. The guest called this a newish point, since people often look outside their own organization for investment expertise[3].
That guest also described an outside investment board that helps define the investment strategies used[3]. Another guest said some committees consist only of family members[3]. Others bring in additional outside members, such as service providers, accountants and attorneys, to round the committee out[3].
Outside experts as a resource
Richard C. Wilson asked a trusts and estates expert whether a CPA or tax attorney must be part of a formal investment committee[3]. The expert said that when sophisticated in house counsel or an in house CPA serves on the committee, outside counsel or an outside accounting firm is a resource for special situations[3].
The expert named structured products, synthetics and sophisticated hedging transactions with significant tax consequences as examples[3]. In those cases, the expert said, an independent outside opinion is needed[3]. The expert did not see a need to sit on the committee personally and described the role as a resource when needed[3].
Structure helps every member
Richard C. Wilson teaches that a charter helps establish the rules for the Committee[2]. It states the purpose, goals and structure of the Committee[2]. The voting power, mission and structure should be reflected in the Charter[2].
Richard C. Wilson writes that it is important to define who makes the decisions or whether investments are made by a Committee vote[2]. Without that, the Committee opens itself up to infighting and indecisiveness[2]. Debate can be healthy when someone is in control of the meeting, usually the CIO or a senior member[2].
Richard C. Wilson also describes strategic committees that may be made up of several outside professionals[2]. These may meet only once or twice a month, while a tactical committee could meet weekly, daily or on demand[2].
It is critical to the success of your Investment Committee to define exactly who makes the decisions or whether investments are made by a Committee vote.
Questions people ask next
How many outside members does Richard C. Wilson suggest?
Richard C. Wilson suggests inviting one to three outside experts as Committee members[1].
Must a tax advisor or accountant sit on the committee?
One trusts and estates expert said a person in that role does not necessarily need to be on the committee and can serve as a resource when needed[3].
Who keeps debate under control?
Richard C. Wilson writes that debate can be healthy when someone controls the meeting, usually the CIO or a senior member[2].
Sources
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
- Richard C. Wilson, How to Start a Family Office
- Richard C. Wilson, Family Office book (Wiley)
Related pages
- Should an endowment investment committee include independent members?
- What belongs in an endowment investment committee charter?
- How often should an endowment investment committee meet?
- How large should an endowment investment committee be?
- How does an investment committee get to consensus?
- How does an endowment investment committee actually work?
Talk to Richard
Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes Endowments.com. If you work at an endowment, advise one, raise capital from one, or run a family office that studies the endowment model, reach him directly. There is no form on this site.
Educational content only. Not investment, tax or legal advice. Endowment figures on profile pages come from the sources named on those pages.