Why a similar time horizon is not the same portfolio
Richard C. Wilson writes that family offices are comfortable with limited liquidity and a long term investing horizon.[1] He has also found that family office investment needs are unique from those of endowments.[2] This guide explains why a similar time horizon does not make the same portfolio, which matters for trustees, investment office staff, fund managers who raise from endowments and families who study the endowment model.[2]
A long horizon is only one input
Wilson says family offices are more comfortable with limited liquidity and a long term investing horizon.[3] He ties this to an ability, unlike some institutional investors, to wait through a difficult cycle.[3] In his account, family offices are not forced by corporate policies or short term panics to sell investments prematurely.[3]
Wilson names lack of liquidity as the principal concern when investing in private equity.[3] When circumstances change and a portfolio needs to be rebalanced, he writes, the ability to redeem money from an investment is incredibly important.[3] A horizon on paper does not remove that concern.[3]
What else shapes a portfolio
Wilson describes the family office as able to manage everything affecting financial health across multiple generations, without restriction on what it can help implement.[2] Life events can change the picture.[2] An unexpected divorce, an untimely death, a child or a new expensive hobby can each change the cash and financial return requirements of a family.[2]
Through his work with family offices and the Family Offices Group association, Wilson found their investment needs to be unique from high net worth individuals, endowments, institutional investment consultants and fund of funds.[2] He adds that family offices are typically more secretive than other investors and often work off referrals.[2]
Capacity also matters. Wilson writes that as wealth grows, the screens, filters and ability to say no may not develop at the same speed.[4] When opportunities become greater than the systems and team can manage, the portfolio reflects that strain.[4]
The fund horizon can differ from the investor horizon
Wilson gives an example from a traditional private equity fund.[3] An investor may commit capital and know the team targets middle market private companies, yet not get to select or approve the individual investments.[3] He calls this a blind pool.[3] Some managers now avoid it, but he describes these funds as the exception.[3]
He also points to timing.[3] Pressure to allocate capital within a five to seven year horizon, rather than a 10 to 20 plus year horizon, could directly change which opportunities are pursued.[3] It could also dissuade single family office investors from reallocating to the next fund.[3]
Wilson sees similar issues on the hedge fund side.[1] Single family offices often express dissatisfaction, and the biggest sticking point is the high fees charged by most managers.[1] The typical structure is a two percent management fee and a twenty percent performance fee.[1]
Tools that fit the portfolio to the investor
Wilson says traditional managers often make up the core part of a family office portfolio.[2] Their benefits are the sheer number of funds, liquidity and, in some cases, a relatively low cost basis.[2] For most family offices, he writes, traditional managers alone are not enough.[2] Many prefer alternative managers for their ability to use multiple types of trading and investment strategies.[2]
Co-investment rights are one concession managers have offered institutional investors to encourage a commitment to a fund.[3] The investor commits as a traditional limited partner and keeps the right to co-invest directly alongside the fund.[3] Wilson recounts that many general partners reconsidered earlier refusals to improve terms, fees and flexibility once investors held greater negotiating power.[3]
Wilson also notes a natural conflict.[4] Those who can help most in a niche of the portfolio are often incentivized to sell a solution that may or may not be in the client's interest.[4] He writes that most self made, ultra wealthy families want to know they are getting value for the money paid.[4]
Steps you can take
- Write down the actual time horizon of the investor, not only the label.
- List the events that could change cash needs or return requirements.
- Check how much liquidity the portfolio needs if conditions change and a rebalance is called for.
- Compare the investor horizon with the fund horizon before committing to a fund.
- Ask whether the investor will see and approve individual investments or invest in a blind pool.
- Review fee structures and ask whether co-investment rights are available.
- Note any conflicts in the advice received on each part of the portfolio.
For investors, the principal concern when investing in private equity is the lack of liquidity.
Questions people ask next
Do endowments and family offices share the same investment needs?
Wilson has found family office investment needs to be unique from those of endowments, high net worth individuals, institutional investment consultants and fund of funds.[2]
Why can a fund horizon matter to a long term investor?
Wilson writes that pressure to allocate capital within a five to seven year horizon, rather than 10 to 20 plus years, could change which opportunities are pursued.[3] It could also dissuade single family office investors from reallocating to the next fund.[3]
What is a co-investment right?
The investor commits to a fund as a traditional limited partner and keeps the right to co-invest directly alongside the fund.[3] That gives the investor two stakes in the company.[3]
Sources
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
- Richard C. Wilson, Family Office book (Wiley)
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
- Richard C. Wilson, Centimillionaire Strategies
Related pages
- Does a long time horizon mean a family can use an endowment mix?
- What governance documents should exist before a policy portfolio is set?
- What does it cost a family to implement an institutional portfolio?
- How does time pressure hurt investment decisions?
- How do you keep a long horizon from becoming an excuse for illiquidity?
- How do you analyze competitors already in an endowment portfolio?
Talk to Richard
Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes Endowments.com. If you work at an endowment, advise one, raise capital from one, or run a family office that studies the endowment model, reach him directly. There is no form on this site.
Educational content only. Not investment, tax or legal advice. Endowment figures on profile pages come from the sources named on those pages.