Trust restrictions that block a consolidated endowment-style model
Richard C. Wilson writes that governance documentation should explain how an office manages changes to its investment policy[1]. That includes the approval process before an investment is made and who decides what share of the portfolio goes to each asset type[1].
Start with who decides
Richard C. Wilson notes that policies may be documented in several places[1]. He still says governance documentation needs to describe how changes to the investment policy are managed[1]. He asks what the approval process is before an investment is made[1]. He also asks who gets to decide what percentage of the portfolio is invested in real estate, hedge funds, private equity or commodities[1].
Controls, conflicts and ethics
Richard C. Wilson asks what controls can be put in place to make sure proper due diligence has been conducted[1]. He asks how conflicts of interest should be disclosed and what actions need to be taken to work through them[1]. He says it is important to have a formal ethics policy, separate from the employee handbook[2]. The ethics policy sets the tone for how an office operates and does business[2]. If there are no set rules on what is acceptable and what is not, it is hard to hold people accountable down the road[2].
Many family offices hire employees, business partners or service providers based on referrals and long term relationships[2]. Richard C. Wilson asks how an office avoids hiring someone just because they are a good friend of the family[2]. He says governance documentation must decide how strict to be when hiring advisors for critical functions such as accounting and reporting, software, investment consulting and legal advice[2].
Cost, talent and performance pressures
Richard C. Wilson describes an institutional model that needs talent in areas such as global taxation, trust and multi generational wealth transfers, portfolio management and risk management[3]. He calls the cost of finding and retaining this much talent an indigestible level of expense for everyone but those with about $3B or more in total assets under management[3]. He estimates that only 1 to 2% of all family offices use this operating model[3].
He also says an expert generalist is expensive to retain[3]. Many times that is why single family offices convert to multi family offices, because the costs are too great for all but the wealthiest individual families[3]. Talent is scarce in this field, and he says the marketplace is so small and trust so important that it can take years to find the right hire[2].
Performance pressure shapes these choices too[4]. Richard C. Wilson writes that fees, a lack of transparency, poor liquidity and lockups have driven single family offices to look elsewhere, including to an in house trading unit that replicates the hedge fund model without the fees[4]. He says that if the returns are not there, an office will think seriously about finding someone else, often internally, to invest the money[4].
Measure people and settle disputes calmly
Richard C. Wilson says everyone from the CEO and CIO down to the analyst and associate should be judged by objective Key Performance Indicators[1]. Ideally these are monitored daily or weekly[1]. They allow objective comparison of team members, which can help when some are family members and others are not[1].
In interviews in his book, one office executive describes working with partners as a way to share practices and to mitigate exposure from a diversification and risk perspective[1]. The same executive says that when a partnership does not work out, the office prefers settling through a discussion over a protracted litigation[1].
Steps you can take
- Write down how changes to the investment policy are approved.
- List who decides the share of the portfolio for each asset type.
- Define the approval process that applies before any investment is made.
- Set the controls that show proper due diligence was done.
- Document how conflicts of interest are disclosed and worked through.
- Adopt a formal ethics policy that is separate from the employee handbook.
- Set objective KPIs for every team member, from the CIO to the analyst.
Everyone from the CEO and CIO down to the analyst and associate should be judged by objective Key Performance Indicators. Ideally these KPIs should be monitored daily or weekly.
Questions people ask next
What governance questions does Richard C. Wilson say to answer first?
He asks how changes to the investment policy are managed, what the approval process is before an investment, and who decides the percentage for each asset type[1]. He also asks what controls confirm due diligence and how conflicts of interest are disclosed[1].
Why does a consolidated model raise cost and talent questions?
Richard C. Wilson says the institutional model needs broad talent, and he calls the cost indigestible for everyone but those with about $3B or more in total assets under management[3]. He adds that expert generalists are expensive to retain[3].
Why does Richard C. Wilson say an ethics policy matters?
He says it sets the tone for how an office operates and does business[2]. Without set rules on what is acceptable, it is hard to hold people accountable later[2].
Sources
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
- Richard C. Wilson, How to Start a Family Office
- Richard C. Wilson, Family Office book (Wiley)
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
Related pages
- How do trust restrictions affect an endowment-style family portfolio?
- Family versus endowment model fit worksheet
- What should be documented when a family adapts an institutional model?
- Should a family pay institutional-style fees on taxable capital?
- Should a family office copy the endowment model?
- Is it a mistake to buy the funds that are up the most?
Talk to Richard
Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes Endowments.com. If you work at an endowment, advise one, raise capital from one, or run a family office that studies the endowment model, reach him directly. There is no form on this site.
Educational content only. Not investment, tax or legal advice. Endowment figures on profile pages come from the sources named on those pages.