Reducing decision overload in a small investment office
Small investment offices make many choices with very few people.[1] This guide draws on writing by Richard C. Wilson about single family offices, which endowment staff, trustees and families who study the endowment model can read for ideas.[1] It shows how clear roles, clear criteria and clear limits can keep each choice smaller.[2]
Start with a small team and a clear committee
Richard C. Wilson writes that single family offices often require one to three senior executives who can wear many hats.[1] He also writes that the talent marketplace is small and trust is important.[1] As a result, it can often take years for a single family office to find the right professional to hire.[1]
Many single family offices are not sure who should sit on their investment committee, how large it should be or how often it should meet.[2] A CIO interviewed for the book said that family office investment committees should mirror the practices of corporate boards.[2] One example is an odd number of members, which helps a committee reach a majority.[2]
Set criteria beyond promised performance
One contributor quoted in the book says that killing the focus on promised performance as the sole decision-making criterion is the hardest job for any family office.[2] The same contributor says the financial industry sells products to families based on hopes, not risks.[2] The same contributor says the family office is there to break that charm, day after day.[2]
An investor interviewed for the book looks for performance on a risk adjusted basis.[3] That investor also looks at the peer group and at the manager.[3] The aim is to decide whether the manager is staying true to what the manager intends to do.[3] For example, a small cap manager might start to hold assets that are no longer small.[3] That investor also puts weight on the people and the process.[3] Given the size of the investor, liquidity could often be an issue.[3]
Give each holding a clear role
Wilson describes traditional managers, such as those who run mutual funds, ETFs and bond funds, as often making up the core part of a family office portfolio.[3] Their benefits include the number of funds, liquidity and, in some cases, a relatively low cost basis.[3] For most family offices, traditional managers alone are not enough.[3]
Many family offices prefer alternative managers such as hedge funds, private equity and venture capital because of the range of strategies they can use.[3] Alternatives are often seen as the way to outperform the general marketplace.[3] Many family offices have also invested heavily in systems, reporting and institutional consultants to help select alternative managers.[3]
Weigh the extra work of in house and direct choices
Wilson explains why many single family offices look elsewhere for returns.[2] Fees are a real concern, and so are a lack of transparency, the potential for huge losses, and poor liquidity and lockups.[2] Perhaps the most important factor is mediocre or poor performance.[2] Whatever the vehicle, if the returns are not there, an office thinks seriously about finding someone else, often internally.[2]
One response is a small trading unit inside the office.[4] Wilson writes that hiring trading talent is expensive.[4] He adds that it might make sense for a family very active in hedge fund investing to open a small unit to avoid fees.[4] He says this is not as common as in house private equity like investment teams.[4]
A direct stake alongside a fund is another path.[4] Fund managers sometimes offer these rights as an inducement for committing capital to a fund.[4] The investor then holds two stakes in the company, one through the fund and one directly.[4] Wilson writes that the risks and rewards of a single direct investment are greater than those of a standard diversified fund structure.[4]
Steps you can take
- Write down who sits on the investment committee, how many members it has and how often it meets.
- Choose an odd number of members so a vote can reach a majority.
- List the criteria for each manager beyond promised performance, including risk adjusted returns, the peer group, the people and the process.
- Sort holdings into core and satellite so each choice has a clear role.
- Check whether each manager is staying true to what the manager set out to do.
- Review fees, transparency, liquidity and lockups before moving a choice inside the office.
- Compare the greater risks and rewards of a direct stake with a diversified fund before committing capital.
The talent marketplace is so small and trust is so important that it can often take years for a single family office to find the right professional to hire.
Questions people ask next
Why do some single family offices bring investing inside the office?
Wilson writes that fees, a lack of transparency, potential for huge losses, and poor liquidity and lockups have driven offices away from some funds.[2] He adds that poor performance is perhaps the most important factor, and that offices then look for someone else, often internally.[2]
What is a direct stake alongside a fund?
The general partner typically sets up a special purpose vehicle that lets the investor hold a single portfolio company alongside the fund.[2] It often reduces the associated fees.[2]
How big is the senior team in a small office?
Wilson writes that single family offices often require one to three senior executives who can wear many hats.[1] Finding the right professional can take years.[1]
Sources
- Richard C. Wilson, How to Start a Family Office
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
- Richard C. Wilson, Family Office book (Wiley)
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
Related pages
- How can an investment office reduce decision overload?
- Investment decision log template
- Investment policy drafting prompts
- Why do managers resist co-investment rights?
- What is the difference between a co-investment and a club deal?
- What is an investment strike zone for direct deals?
Talk to Richard
Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes Endowments.com. If you work at an endowment, advise one, raise capital from one, or run a family office that studies the endowment model, reach him directly. There is no form on this site.
Educational content only. Not investment, tax or legal advice. Endowment figures on profile pages come from the sources named on those pages.