Family Office ClubText or WhatsApp (808) 600-9260 · WhatsApp

Raising from private equity LPs including endowments

This page sets out how Richard C. Wilson describes the way limited partners judge private equity funds, and what fund managers face when they raise capital from them.[1] It matters for anyone on either side of a fund commitment, because Wilson writes that investors weigh fees, performance and control.[1][2]

What limited partners weigh

Richard C. Wilson writes that fees are a real concern for investors.[2] Wilson writes that fees have led many single family offices to look elsewhere for alpha, including by launching an in house trading unit to replicate the hedge fund model internally without the fees.[1] He lists other issues too, such as a lack of transparency, poor liquidity and lockups.[2]

Wilson writes that an investor will put up with many inconveniences when a manager produces strong returns consistently.[1] What investors will not accept is consistently bad performance added to other issues.[1] He adds that this holds whether the vehicle is a hedge fund, a private equity fund or any other.[1] If the returns are not there, the investor thinks seriously about finding someone else, often internally, with the hope of better results and fewer headaches.[1]

How private equity funds earn and carry risk

Wilson describes a fee structure that includes a performance fee of 20% of the profits generated by the fund.[1] The fund manager deploys the capital over the next few years into several companies that the general partner believes are undervalued, poorly managed, or can otherwise be improved.[1]

To buy out a company, private equity funds use borrowed money financed by banks or other lenders.[1] The fund may commit only a fraction of equity toward the deal value and borrow the rest.[1] If the deal succeeds, the fund can reap large gains for its limited partners.[1] If it fails, the company usually protects the fund and its investors from the full losses, yet Wilson notes there are many examples of failed deals that led to heavy losses for investors.[1]

A family office executive Richard C. Wilson interviewed explained the carry and the hurdle.[3] The carry can range from 5% to 20% or more depending on the structure of the deal.[3] A hurdle rate could be anywhere from 5% to 10% or 15%, and generally it sits between 8% and 12%.[3] That means the limited partners have to receive at least that return on their money before the general partners start to share in the profits.[3]

Co investment rights

Wilson writes that general partners have resisted co investment rights for several reasons.[1] The co investment adds a layer of complexity to the fund.[2] The general partner gives up capital that would have been invested under the standard fund vehicle.[2] Other limited partners are more likely to ask for similar arrangements.[2] By allowing co investments, the general partner also encourages future co investments and direct investments by investors.[2]

Investors ask for these rights for many of the same reasons that managers have opposed them.[1] Limited partners hope to reduce overall fees on private equity investments, manage more investments internally, gain more control through investments in companies, and gradually build an in house direct investment platform.[2] The cost and added complexity of building a structure can be burdensome on the general partner.[2] This is true whether it is a special purpose vehicle for a single co investment or a co investment fund.[2]

Where private equity fits in a portfolio

Wilson describes traditional managers as those who run mutual funds, ETFs, bond funds and similar products.[4] They often make up the core of a portfolio, and their benefits are the volume of funds, liquidity and a relatively low cost in some cases.[4] For most family offices, he writes, traditional managers alone are not enough.[4]

Many family offices prefer alternative managers, including private equity and venture capital, because of their ability to use many types of strategies.[4] Alternatives are often looked at as the solution to outperforming the general marketplace or economy.[4] In a set of lessons Wilson records from one investor, persistence matters, partnerships and collaboration are key, and building real businesses works better than building assets to flip in a few years.[2] The same lessons say it pays to know what you are doing.[2]

Steps you can take

  1. Review the fees, the carry and the hurdle rate of each private equity fund before committing.
  2. Track fund performance over time and compare it with the fees paid.
  3. Ask managers about transparency, liquidity and lockups early in the conversation.
  4. Decide in advance whether co investment rights matter for the relationship.
  5. Understand how borrowed money is used in buyout deals and what happens if a deal fails.
  6. Match traditional and alternative managers to the role each plays in the portfolio.

For most family offices, the use of traditional investment managers alone is not enough.

Richard C. Wilson, Family Office book (Wiley)

Questions people ask next

Why do investors look for co investment rights?

Wilson writes that limited partners hope to reduce overall fees, manage more investments internally, gain more control and gradually build an in house direct investment platform.[2]

What is a hurdle rate in a private equity fund?

A family office executive Richard C. Wilson interviewed said it is the return limited partners must receive before the general partners start to share in the profits.[3] Generally it sits between 8% and 12%.[3]

What makes investors consider leaving a fund?

Wilson writes that consistently bad performance is what investors will not put up with, whatever the vehicle.[1] Fees, transparency and liquidity also play a part.[2]

Sources
  1. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
  2. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
  3. Richard C. Wilson interview with a family office executive
  4. Richard C. Wilson, Family Office book (Wiley)

Related pages

Talk to Richard

Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes Endowments.com. If you work at an endowment, advise one, raise capital from one, or run a family office that studies the endowment model, reach him directly. There is no form on this site.

Educational content only. Not investment, tax or legal advice. Endowment figures on profile pages come from the sources named on those pages.