How taxable families differ from tax-exempt endowments
Taxable families and tax exempt endowments sit in different places on taxes.[1] This guide sets out the difference as Richard C. Wilson describes it in his writing and interviews. It is written for trustees, investment office staff, fund managers who raise from endowments and families who study the endowment model.
The core tax difference
Richard C. Wilson writes that investments by high net worth individuals and families are usually taxable.[1] He sets that against more tax efficient vehicles and tax exempt entities.[1] His examples of tax exempt entities are government and corporate pension funds, endowments and charitable foundations.[1] The same point appears in the direct investments edition of his book.[2]
One example is individual purchase of real estate.[1] In that case, many high net worth individuals buy property outside a pooled fund structure or sophisticated vehicle.[1] The direct investments edition describes the same individual purchase.[2]
Why families favor income producing property
Wilson says two of the most popular real estate investments in his experience with families are apartment buildings and hotels.[1] Many families prefer them because of the income component.[1] Apartment buildings produce income from tenant rents.[1] Hotels produce income from room rentals.[1]
Steady, consistent income is attractive to wealthy families with a long term investing mindset.[1] Each family's investment mandate varies.[1] The same passage appears in the direct investments edition.[2]
How families structure and govern their capital
In a pooled private equity real estate fund, the general partner charges a 2% management fee and a 20% performance fee.[2] The fund invests its capital pool in a number of portfolio companies or investments with a finite window for exiting, typically 5 to 7 years.[2] Borrowed capital tends to increase returns and allows larger, debt fueled acquisitions.[2]
Many family offices maintain an investment committee, whatever their investment model.[3] Its role is to help make strategic investment decisions, evaluate or select fund managers, discuss portfolio construction and risk management, and ensure the long term preservation of capital under the investment policy it has been given.[3] Single family office committees do not always have a formal structure and are often made up of just 3 to 5 professionals, sometimes including 1 to 2 external experts or consultants.[3] Many times these committees are less than democratic.[3] Votes are sometimes seen as feedback for the patriarch, but not always followed.[3]
Wilson describes six levels of potential control in an investment.[4] They run from strategic planning and sourcing, through screening, due diligence and negotiation, to management of holdings and exits.[4] He says the most consistent approach he has seen is three levels of outsourcing and control, diversified across assets and control levels.[4] He also says no generic investment advice is ever possible or appropriate.[4]
How families handle tax questions and talent
A family office executive Richard C. Wilson interviewed described how tax questions come up for families.[5] In the typical scenario, a hedge fund might have a mirror fund that is an international fund, which foreign trusts and foreign companies controlled by US families can access.[5] There might also be an insurance dedicated fund, which makes the hedge fund an eligible investment for private placement life insurance policies.[5] These are examples of what was described and not advice for any reader.
Wilson also writes that endowment funds are fertile grounds for finding slightly under paid but bright and well groomed talent for managing a family office portfolio.[6] He lists this under cherry picking, which means targeting professionals at institutional firms.[6] The same passage appears in another edition.[1]
Steps you can take
- Note whether each holding sits in a taxable or a tax exempt vehicle before comparing results.
- Ask what income a family expects from a property such as an apartment building or a hotel.
- Read the management fee, performance fee and exit window of a pooled fund.
- Write down the investment committee's role, size and how its votes are used.
- Map each investment across the six levels of control and note which levels are outsourced.
- Bring tax structure questions to qualified tax advisers.
- Look at institutional firms, including endowment funds, when building a family office team.
These investments by HNW individuals and families are usually taxable, compared to more tax efficient vehicles or tax-exempt entities like government and corporate pension funds, endowments, charitable foundations, etc.
Questions people ask next
Are family investments usually taxable?
Wilson writes that investments by high net worth individuals and families are usually taxable.[1] He lists endowments, charitable foundations and pension funds as tax exempt entities.[1]
Why do many families like apartment buildings and hotels?
In Wilson's experience, families prefer them for the income from tenant rents and room rentals.[1] Steady, consistent income is attractive to families with a long term investing mindset.[1]
What does a family investment committee do?
It helps make strategic investment decisions, evaluate or select fund managers, and discuss portfolio construction and risk management.[3] It also works to ensure the long term preservation of capital under the investment policy it has been given.[3]
Sources
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
- Richard C. Wilson, Family Office book (Wiley)
- Richard C. Wilson, Centimillionaire Strategies
- Richard C. Wilson interview with a family office executive
- Richard C. Wilson, How to Start a Family Office
Related pages
- What should families borrow from endowment manager research?
- How does an endowment mission differ from a family office mission?
- How do families borrow from the endowment model without copying it?
- What families can take from endowment manager research
- Fee stacks on long-horizon taxable and tax-exempt capital
- Why do endowments and pension funds invest differently than families?
Talk to Richard
Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes Endowments.com. If you work at an endowment, advise one, raise capital from one, or run a family office that studies the endowment model, reach him directly. There is no form on this site.
Educational content only. Not investment, tax or legal advice. Endowment figures on profile pages come from the sources named on those pages.