Family Office ClubText or WhatsApp (808) 600-9260 · WhatsApp

Direct investing capacity compared with an institutional bench

This guide compares building direct investing capacity inside an office with relying on an institutional bench of outside managers. Richard C. Wilson writes about this choice for family offices, and endowment trustees, staff and families who study endowments can read his questions as a plain checklist.[1] It matters because a direct deal takes time and money, and an experienced outside fund is often the alternative.[2]

Start with the benchmark

Richard C. Wilson writes that a direct investment is judged on expenses incurred, return on investment, and how it performed relative to other uses of the same capital.[1] A common benchmark for equity investments is the S&P 500 Index. Investors look to achieve alpha, which he describes as an annual return greater than the benchmark.[1]

If the net return is at or below the S&P 500 or a similar equity index, he writes that the deal was likely a poor use of capital.[1] The reason is that an index fund or stock portfolio could have done the same job without the time intensive, laborious and expensive direct deal.[1]

Questions to ask before building direct capacity

Another factor to consider in direct deals is whether the allocation should have gone to an outside investment manager.[1] Richard C. Wilson gives a real estate example. A family office that is bullish on apartments in Beijing could buy and manage a building itself, or it could allocate to an experienced real estate fund that manages Beijing properties and holds a similar investing philosophy.[1]

He lists the factors to weigh. They include the fees charged for managing the capital and whether those fees are taken from profits on the deal.[2] They include how competent the outside team is compared with your own.[2] They also include whether you would have less transparency and control than you would have investing directly, and how concentrated your committed capital would be in the area you want to invest in.[2]

What an outside bench offers and what staff check

In an interview Richard C. Wilson conducted, a wealth advisor said real estate exposure comes almost all through private equity funds, and those funds then do the direct investing.[3] The advisor said the firm would not suggest that a client buy a property, because the firm does not have the expertise.[3] The same advisor noted that some firms are very good, with national coverage and a strong network, but they charge promotes and other fees.[3]

Another interviewed investor described how an institutional team reviews managers. They look at performance on a risk adjusted basis.[3] They look at the peer group and at whether a manager stays true to what it intends to do.[3] That investor said the focus is on the people and the process, and that established investment shops are often preferred.[3]

When families bring investing in house

Richard C. Wilson writes that concern about fees has led many single family offices to look elsewhere for alpha. Some launched an in house trading unit to replicate the hedge fund model without the fees.[1] Other issues also pushed families away, such as a lack of transparency, the potential for huge losses, and poor liquidity and lockups.[1] He adds that perhaps the most important factor is simply mediocre or poor performance.[1]

If the returns are not there, a single family office thinks seriously about finding someone else, often internally, to invest the money.[1] Hiring trading talent is expensive. A family that is very active in hedge fund investing may find that a small proprietary trading unit makes sense, in order to avoid fees.[2] He notes this is not as common as in house private equity like investment teams.[2]

On staffing, Richard C. Wilson describes endowment funds as fertile ground for finding slightly under paid but bright and well groomed talent to manage a family office portfolio.[4] He also describes recruiting from institutional firms such as multi family offices, tax advisory firms, private equity funds and investment banks.[4]

Steps you can take

  1. Write down the expenses, net return and alternative use of capital for each direct deal.
  2. Compare each net return with an equity index such as the S&P 500.
  3. Ask whether an experienced outside fund could give the same exposure.
  4. List fees, team competence, transparency, control and concentration for both routes.
  5. Review outside managers on risk adjusted performance against a peer group.
  6. Complete a one page direct investment worksheet and use it as a talking document with the team.

Another factor to consider in direct deals is whether an allocation should have been placed with a third-party investment manager.

Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)

Questions people ask next

How does Richard C. Wilson judge a direct deal?

He looks at expenses incurred, return on investment, and performance relative to how the capital could otherwise be used.[1] A net return at or below an equity index such as the S&P 500 suggests a poor use of capital.[1]

Why do some families move investing in house?

Richard C. Wilson writes that fees, lack of transparency, poor liquidity and lockups, and poor performance push them to look elsewhere.[1] Some then build in house teams to replicate a hedge fund model without the fees.[1]

What do investors check when choosing an outside manager?

One interviewed investor looks at risk adjusted performance, the peer group, and whether the manager stays true to its intent.[3] Richard C. Wilson also lists fees, team competence, transparency, control and concentration.[2]

Sources
  1. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
  2. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
  3. Richard C. Wilson, Family Office book (Wiley)
  4. Richard C. Wilson, How to Start a Family Office

Related pages

Talk to Richard

Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes Endowments.com. If you work at an endowment, advise one, raise capital from one, or run a family office that studies the endowment model, reach him directly. There is no form on this site.

Educational content only. Not investment, tax or legal advice. Endowment figures on profile pages come from the sources named on those pages.